Enigma 398: Down on the farm
From New Scientist #1548, 19th February 1987 [link]
Farmer O. R. Midear has crossed a turnip with a mangel to get a tungel, and he now has many fields of tungels. As a tungel expert, he looks at a tungel to see if it is red or not, if it is smooth or not, and if it is firm or not. He knows that if a tungel is red then it is smooth.
Regulations have just been introduced which put fields of tungels into classes A, B, C, D, E; a field may be in more than one class.
Class A: All fields containing no red tungel.
Class B: All fields containing no smooth tungel.
Class C: All fields in which every red tungel is firm.
Class D: All fields in which every smooth tungel is firm.
Class E: All fields containing a red tungel which is not firm.
To test Farmer Midear’s understanding of the regulations he was asked to say which of the following statements are true.
1. If a field is in A then it is in B.
2. If a field is in B then it is in A.
3. If a field is in C then it is in B.
4. If a field is in B then it is in C.
5. If a field is in C then it is in D.
6. If a field is in D then it is in C.
7. If a field is in D then it is not in E.
8. If a field is not in E then it is in C.
9. In every field there is a tungel such that if it is not red then the field is in A.
What should Farmer Midear’s answer be?